Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports

Cleaning the gutters is a common task that must be done to avoid the problem of water entering your home. Climbing on your roof or hanging from a ladder is certainly not the safest or most enjoyable way to spend your weekend. However, one way to reduce or even eliminate this task is by installing gutter protectors.

Gutter guards reduce the need to regularly clean leaves, branches, pine needles, and other obstructions. Instead, these potential blockages are washed over the edge or blown off the surface by the wind. The most common channel width at 5 “, so this is the typical protection dimension.

It is important to note that some guards can slide under the roof shingles if there is not enough room to mount them on the front panel. You should always avoid placing the edge of the bumpers under the shingles because it can void your roof warranties.

5 Best Gutter Guards Reviews

  • FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System
  • EZ-Quick-10 Gutter Guard
  • Amerimax Home 86670 Filter Gutter Guard
  • Smart Screen GPS401 Gutter Protection Covers
  • Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Raptor Gutter Guard

#5 FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System

View At Amazon

FlexxPoint Gutter Guard features a three-point design that slows the flow of water over the surface of the guard, giving it time to completely drain into the gutter.

  • It has a profile that allows airflow under the leaves or debris that are on the surface to prevent them from sticking.

  • Includes steel fasteners to mount directly to the edge of the gutter and fascia dash.

  • It comes in four-foot sections in matt aluminum, white or black.

  • Made in the USA.


#4 EZ-Quick-10 Gutter Guard

View At Amazon

EZ-GUTTER protectors are designed to simply snap into the existing channel profile so no fasteners are required.

  • Constructed of aluminum mesh for durable oxidation resistance.

  • It has a curved profile that is retained by tension, which facilitates its placement and removal.

  • The mesh design allows water to flow through while blocking debris.

  • Includes a 3/4 ”notch at the end of each section to overlap and create a continuous surface.

  • Designed to fit in a 5 “gutter.


#3 Amerimax Home 86670 Filter Gutter Guard

View At Amazon

Amerimax has developed a really good mesh-type gutter protector that is perfect for K-style gutters that are 4, 5, or 6 inches tall.

Due to the fine mesh surface, this special gutter protection is perfectly capable of trapping small particles of dirt and leaves, and at the same time prevents all kinds of insects and living things from entering the gutter system.

The protectors are made of rigid PVC and are therefore durable. They are very easy to install due to their locking mechanism. The instructions are very easy to follow and always make sure the gutter protectors are installed with the filters facing up.

  • Snap design.
  • Easy installation.
  • Feinmaschiger filter.
  • Captures fine debris.


#2 Smart Screen GPS401 Gutter Protection Covers

View At Amazon

The Smart Screen Gutter Guard features all-aluminum construction for long-lasting durability and rust resistance.

  • It has a design profile that provides additional stiffness to the gutter.

  • It comes in four-foot lengths for easy handling and installation.

  • Fits standard 5 “wide gutters.

  • Includes mounting screws.


#1 Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Raptor Gutter Guard

View At Amazon

The Raptor Gutter Guard is made from Type 304 stainless steel to provide resistance to rust and corrosion.

  • Equipped with a micro-mesh that allows water to flow and debris to pass through.

  • It features a V-Bend mesh profile that helps add stiffness and prevent sagging.

  • Prevent small clogs from entering the gutter with 900 holes per square inch.

  • Designed to fit a standard 5 “gutter.

  • NOTE: Depending on roof configuration, it can be installed under the edge of existing shingles, which I do not recommend. Consult your installation guide for alternative mounting methods, such as attaching to the front panel.


Types of gutter guards

There are several different types of guards and each has its own pros and cons, as outlined below.

Brush Guards – Looks like a bottle brush with bristles wrapped around a wire core.

  • Pros: affordable. Easy to install. Stops large debris.

  • Cons: Won’t stop small debris. Less attractive when viewed from an upstairs room.

Foam protectors: a simple foam profile that fits inside the gutter.

  • Pros: affordable. Easy to install.

  • Cons: does not stop the growth of plants or algae.

Screen protectors – Perforated metal (typically aluminum) top cap with drain holes. Note that by the name “screen” I mean a sheet of metal with holes, not a mesh.

  • Pros: Easily snaps or snaps in place. Adds rigidity and a clean appearance to the gutter.

  • Cons: more expensive than other solutions. You can create a “home” for pests. Difficult to cut.

Mesh Protectors – Comes in a variety of mesh materials and densities.

  • Pros: affordable. Easier to cut than a metal screen.

  • Cons: Less stiff than screen options, so it can fail under heavy debris.

Micromesh protectors: very fine mesh density.

  • Pros: They are usually mounted on a frame so they are less flimsy. Block large and small debris.

  • Cons: May become clogged with small granular debris. More expensive than some other options.

Buying Guide For Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports

Keep in mind that the material is not the only criterion to consider before buying a gutter.

It is important to focus on all the elements of implementation:

  • The dimensions of the gutter: in addition to the material, the dimensions of a gutter are important. In a rainy region, avoid shallow models, subject to overflows.
  • The architecture of the roof: the model chosen also depends on the dimensions and layout of your roof. Not all gutters adapt to just any type of roof.
  • Installation: all-metal gutters must be welded by professionals during installation. If you want to take care of the installation, then opt for a seamless gutter.
  • Local planning rules: you should know that some municipalities prohibit the use of several gutter materials. Find out about the local town planning plan for your city by contacting your town hall.


Our lists and rankings are always created regarding the quality and price of the product, in this case, Gutters. We take into account the best and cheapest prices, as well as the most outstanding ones from Amazon. But always with good ratings and opinions from customers who have already bought the product.

We also select the best offers and the biggest discounts on Gutters guards consumer reports. We seek the best for you. Our lists are continually updated to always offer you fully updated information, so we never miss a bargain.


Leave a Comment