Best Pillow Consumer Reports

Do you have trouble sleeping? Do you regularly wake up with neck pain, and can’t really rest? Maybe it’s time for a change of pillow! We tend to choose our bedding without giving it much thought. However, much progress has been made in this area.

Thus, there are now top comfort pillows with shape memory that adapt to your movements and the way you sleep. There are also orthopedic models. In reality, it can even become difficult to navigate because the offer is so rich and complete.

Reviews On Best Pillows Consumer Reports

#5 Utopia Bedding Gusseted Pillow

View At Amazon

Do you sometimes have a little trouble sleeping without having severe pain? Would you like to make your bed warmer and more comfortable while limiting the investment? Then you can opt for the Utopia Microfiber Gusset Pillows, the improved and softer version of classic pillows.

What we think of Utopia Microfiber Gusset Pillows

Here you get a set of 2 pillows, which are basically white with a colored border. You can opt for gray or blue. There are also two sizes: Queen, smaller and a little more flexible, and King. We believe that they are suitable for the majority of people who do not have too much neck pain.

We must salute the attention that has been paid to design, which turns out to be both sober and chic and can perfectly adapt to different decorative styles.

In terms of comfort, the cushions are quite soft. It’s very pleasant as long as you don’t move too much at night, since you quickly find yourself wrapped in your cocoon. This is basically made possible by the microfiber padding, which is soft without being too flexible.

But what we like most about these products is the good value for the money offered. You benefit from a double seam which reinforces the structure.

The result: the pillows are difficult to damage. Inflation takes 48 to 72 hours but can be speeded up with a few tips, like letting them sunbathe.

We have very few complaints, but there is still a downside regarding maintenance. While in theory you can machine run Utopia Microfiber Gusset Pillows, it shortens their lifespan, and the manufacturer explicitly advises hand washing, which is obviously longer and more tedious.

What’s Good

  • The simple and complete sleep kit.
  • Set of 2 pillows.
  • Soft and relaxing feeling for the neck and head.
  • 2 colors: blue or gray piping.
  • Hand cleaning and dry cleaning recommended.

What’s Bad

  • Sometimes a little frustrating interview

#4 UTTU Sandwich Pillow Queen

View At Amazon

What are you looking for is a pillow capable of fully bending to your requirements, whether in terms of comfort or height? This is exactly what the Uttu Sandwich Pillow offers. This memory foam pillow comes at a very reasonable price and can actually help you fight difficult to sleep.

What we think of the Uttu Sandwich Pillow

Please note that this product is certified OKEO-TEX and CertiPUR-US, two organizations whose objective is to assess the quality of textiles.

It also has the certification of the International Sleep Products Association, a good point to weigh since the latter is above all an association of professionals in the sector.

Either way, the Uttu Sandwich Pillow has an ingenious design that makes it very flexible. For example, you have the option of removing one of the layers of memory foam to adjust it in height.

The foam itself is worthy of mention. It is homemade, exclusive to the Uttu brand, and dynamic: it adapts very well to the shape of your body, whether you sleep on your stomach or your back.

In addition, it is designed in such a way that the pillow does not flatten out and also does not get too hard when it is cool. Thus, with the neck and head well supported and a pillow that remains cozy and soft, comfort is assured.

But it’s not just the foam that’s interesting, since the pillowcase has also received special attention. Designed in polyester and bamboo, it is hypoallergenic and in particular, offers excellent resistance to the enemies of quiet nights such as dust mites. In addition, it is simply a machine washable.

You will understand, the manufacturing quality is very good and the lifespan is long, you also benefit from a five-year warranty.

Our only regret ultimately concerns the fact that there is only one size, Queen, and that the design is still very basic and not very elegant.

What’s Good

  • The most customizable.
  • Adjustable in height from 8.89 to 11.94 cm / 3.5 to 4.7 in.
  • Pillowcase 60% polyester, 40% bamboo, hypoallergenic, machine washable.
  • Resistant to dust mites.
  • Uttu dynamic foam that adapts to your sleeping habits.
  • ISPA, CertiPUR-US, and OEKO-Tex certified.

What’s Bad

  • Mono-format, not very pretty

#3 Utopia Bedding Premium Plush Pillow

View At Amazon

Are you having a bad night’s sleep, but don’t feel like spending a lot of money on a pillow? The Utopia Super Plush Premium Pillows can help.

This set is in fact generally offered at very affordable prices, while offering a level of comfort that does not equal the best pillows but is very acceptable.

What we think of the Utopia Super Plush Premium Pillows

Let’s first mention the main flaw of these products: the comfort is lower than what you will be able to find for a little more expensive.

Of course, this is an inevitable compromise in this price range. However, we were rather pleasantly surprised in this respect.

The biggest problem is that the cushions are quite rigid and do not have shape memory. Therefore, they will not be suitable for everyone.

But their padding nevertheless offers a very pleasant downy feeling, and their fairly inflated side allows good neck support when you sleep on your back.

There is really no frills here: you just have two cotton pillows with fiber filling. Their lifespan is quite fair, but you have to expect that they will run out and flatten out faster than other references offered for a bit more expensive.

Nevertheless, the solidity remains honest, within particular double stitching at the angles which make it possible to avoid big problems.

If you follow the manufacturer’s recommendations and wash by hand, you can keep your set for a long time, making it a good value for money.

There is only one size: “standard”, or Queen. Note that the interpretation of the Queen size of Utopia is smaller than that sometimes found elsewhere.

The design is extremely sober, white. It, therefore, does not have much character but has the advantage of adapting quite easily to all types of interior.

What’s Good

  • The all-in-one option at the right price-performance ratio.
  • Set of 2 striped cotton pillows, 200 thread count.
  • Rather rigid and flat, effective for good support.
  • Double-stitched corners.
  • Machine washable.

What’s Bad

  • Limited comfort compared to other products

#2 Memory Foam Pillow

View At Amazon

Do your sleeping difficulties recur and become more and more difficult to bear? Are you looking to have flawless bedding equipment from A to Z, even if it means paying the price? You may then be interested in Save & Soft Cooling Gel Memory Foam Pillow, an expensive product but ideal for improving your well-being.

What we think of the Save & Soft Cooling Gel Memory Foam Pillow

Know first that the goal here is to offer good support and improved alignment of the spine, which mechanically implies that the feeling is less soft and firmer than on other products. It takes time to adapt, but we quickly find ourselves finding it very comfortable and relieving for the joints.

Before going any further, let’s note a defect that may be prohibitive for some buyers: the unpleasant smell of memory foam is quite significant, despite the supplied bamboo cover which smells slightly of aloe vera. The latter is latex-free but must be hand washed.

Save & Soft does offer a better pillowcase, but sold separately and which can potentially add a significant cost to your purchase. For the pillow itself, it’s a great long-term investment. Plus, you get a 90-day return policy in the event you are unsatisfied.

The cooling gel is very practical since it keeps the pillow cool and pleasant even in humid or hot weather. So you sleep well even in summer when it is very hot. It is very popular with the elderly.

The size of the pillow is quite modest, rather close to Queen sizes. But this is not necessarily a defect, since it allows for example to make it your personal travel cushion.

What’s Good

  • The well-being reference at the top.
  • A cooling gel, the pillow is always fresh and pleasant even in summer.
  • Zero latex pillowcase, bamboo fiber scented with aloe vera to wash by hand.
  • Perfect for the elderly.

What’s Bad

  • Cover to be purchased separately

#1 BedStory Pillows for Sleeping

View At Amazon

According to the manufacturer, using the BedStory Luxury Hotel Pillows allows you to sleep on a cloud. Without going that far, they can be very comfortable but are intended for a particular audience.

They are indeed mainly suitable for people looking for soft support and who have no health concerns.

What we think of BedStory Luxury Hotel Pillows

Our recommendation is to consider purchasing this set of 2 pillows if you don’t have too much trouble sleeping but would like even more comfort to quietly lose yourself in your dreams. Indeed, they are very soft, to the point that you can almost bundle up in them.

The manufacturer assesses the stiffness himself at 4/10. On the other hand, the maintenance of the neck or the vertebrae is de facto less good than on other references.

As a result, if you are looking to improve your well-being and avoid pain, this is not the best option. We do not recommend this choice for the elderly either.

Once that said, the comfort remains really top-notch: you sleep well, especially since you benefit from a large thickness allowing you to position yourself at the height that suits you best. In terms of size, you also have several options. No problem, so to adapt to your bed.

The design is minimalist, but the light gray border adds a bit of charm. In addition, the cover is hypoallergenic, in particular, you are protected from dust mites. The plush padding is as classic as it is effective.

Price-wise, this is a more expensive kit than what we have seen on average. However, this is justified by very solid manufacturing and a 5-year warranty. However, be aware that after a few months the pillows flatten out, so you really have to want something soft.

What’s Good

  • The softest.
  • Set of 2.
  • Very elastic, good thickness.
  • Rated 4/10 in stiffness by the manufacturer.
  • Hypoallergenic, resistant to dust mites.
  • Simple but nice design.

What’s Bad

  • A little more expensive than the competition

Buying Guide For Best Pillow Consumer Reports

Do you know exactly what your goals are, have you defined your sleep style, and are you all set to make a purchase? Perfect! But how do you rate a pillow? Here are some tips to help you find an honest value for money that can really meet all your expectations.


The pillows are generally quite accessible. There are two main sales formats: either a single product or a pack of 2.


  • $ 20 to $ 30 for entry-level models that are simply comfortable.
  • A little over $ 40 or $ 45 for intermediate shape memory references, with or without cooling gel.
  • About $ 50 to $ 55 for top comfort, shape-memory orthopedic pillows with cooling gel.

Note that these are indicative amounts because the prices can change completely according to the size or the color chosen for example.

Type Of Pillow

There are several types of pillows, which can be combined with each other. Beyond the standard models, you can find references:

  • Orthopedic or chiropractic, intended to reduce pain in the neck or cervical spine.
  • Shape memory: padded with special foam that adapts to your habits as you sleep.
  • Cooling gel: which always stays cool, and is perfect for ventilating the elderly in the summer, but can give off a bad odor.


There are so-called “standard” sizes for pillows, which vary depending on whether you are facing a square or rectangle model. However, brands often have their own interpretation, and in truth simply relying on the name chosen can cause unpleasant surprises. It is therefore absolutely necessary to check.

However, in most manufacturers, we find this diagram:

Standard refers to fairly small models.

Queen designates slightly larger models, designed to be well adapted to the morphology and comfort of women.

King refers to larger models, designed to suit male body shapes and people with fuller physiognomy.


The weight of a pillow can be a good indicator to assess the strength or amount of padding. Moreover, there is a dedicated measure for textiles:

  • The gram / m² or GSM. For pillows, it is generally high, over 300. This indicates good resistance and more solid support for the head.


Pillows can be filled with microfiber, plush, cotton… there are many options, but polyester microfiber largely dominates the market.

It is the padding that gives the pillow its soft or rigid side.

Some brands offer their own stiffness scale.

For some materials, like cotton, you can also evaluate it by the number of threads, but this is rarely indicated. This is simply the number of horizontal and vertical wires per in.

The higher it is, the softer the pillow is, and stays softer over time.


The majority of pillows are now offered directly with a light pillowcase or cover. This can be made of various materials. Today, the choice is often cotton or bamboo fiber.

The advantage of the latter is its hypoallergenic properties.

What does that mean? That it attracts little microbes, dust mites, or other allergens. Therefore, if you are disturbed in your sleep due to allergies, this is a great option.

The pillowcase, when it goes through the machine, greatly facilitates maintenance.

However, most manufacturers recommend hand washing and dry cleaning for pillows and pillowcases to ensure longer life.


We do our best to offer you a comparison allowing you to choose the best possible pillow. If we missed any information or new models, please feel free to leave a comment below or send us a message.

Leave a Comment